top of page

The Difference Between Toxic Honour and True Biblical Honour

Writer: Stuart McEwing
Stuart McEwing
6 days ago
6 min read

The Bible has quite a lot to say about honour, and it consistently presents honour as something that ought to characterise our relationships with one another.

But there is a significant difference between a culture that values honour and a culture that has become obsessed with it.


In some environments, honour becomes less about recognising the dignity and worth of others and more about maintaining one's own position. Authority becomes something that must not be questioned. Reputation becomes something more important than truth. Respect becomes something that must be demanded. And "covering up sin," "maintaining harmony" and accusations of relgiousity are used like blankets to damp down questions Like weapons to keep people in their place.


This is what I would call toxic honour culture.


The tragedy is that such a culture can look remarkably respectable. It can use the language of biblical submission, respect for authority, loyalty and the importance of family or community. But beneath the surface, its values are often quite different from those of the kingdom of God.


So what does genuine, biblical honour actually look like?



The problem with honour as status


A toxic honour culture is fundamentally concerned with status. It measures people according to their position, influence, achievements, reputation or place within a social hierarchy.


In such a culture, honour is something to be acquired and defended. People are concerned with how they are perceived, whether they are being given the respect they believe they deserve, and whether their authority is being properly acknowledged.


The result is that relationships can become transactional. I honour you because you occupy a position above me, and you honour me for what I can do for you. The value of honour is determined, at least in part, by the relative status of the people involved. Its uses people to achieve means, instead of treating people as ends in themselves with an inherent dignity.


This creates a particular problem when honour is attached to authority. Leaders can come to expect unquestioning loyalty. Those under their authority can feel that raising concerns, asking difficult questions or exposing wrongdoing is somehow dishonourable. The preservation of reputation can become more important than the pursuit of truth. And this is where honour becomes toxic. It ceases to serve people and instead demands that people serve it.


Jesus turns the world's understanding of honour upside down

One of the most striking things about Jesus is how consistently he challenges conventional ideas about status and greatness.


In Mark 10:42–45, Jesus addresses the disciples after James and John have sought positions of honour beside him in his glory. He points to the way rulers of the Gentiles exercise authority, lording it over those under them. But, he says, it is not to be that way among his followers.


Instead, whoever wants to become great must become a servant, and whoever wants to be first must become a slave of all. Jesus is not simply suggesting that leaders should be a little more considerate. He is challenging the very framework by which greatness and honour are measured.


In the kingdom of God, greatness is not established by how many people defer to you, but by how willingly you serve others.


And Jesus does not merely teach this principle. He embodies it. The Son of Man came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.

Think about the significance of that. The one who possesses the greatest possible claim to honour willingly takes the position of a servant. He does not need to demand recognition or defend his status. His greatness is demonstrated through self-giving love.


This is a radically different understanding of honour.


Biblical honour is something we give, not something we demand


Paul writes in Romans 12:10:

"Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honour."


There is something quite beautiful about this instruction. Paul does not encourage believers to compete for recognition, but to compete in giving it away.

The direction of honour is outward.


We are to recognise the value of others, to treat them with dignity and to give appropriate regard to their contributions and circumstances. And importantly, this is not restricted to people who occupy positions of authority or who have something to offer us in return.

In 1 Corinthians 12, Paul develops this principle in his discussion of the body of Christ. He explains that the parts of the body which seem weaker are indispensable, and that the parts we consider less honourable are treated with special honour.


This is a remarkable reversal of ordinary social instincts.


The world tends to give honour to those who already possess influence, visibility and status. Paul describes a community in which honour is deliberately extended to those who might otherwise be overlooked.


Biblical honour, then, is not simply about respecting people according to their position. It is about recognising their inherent worth and treating them accordingly. It is not something we demand from others to reinforce our own importance. It is something we willingly extend because of their God-given nature as his image-bearers.


Honour must never become an excuse for avoiding the truth


Perhaps one of the most damaging expressions of toxic honour is the idea that protecting someone's reputation is more important than confronting their wrongdoing.

This can be particularly dangerous in religious communities, where respect for spiritual leadership, institutional loyalty and the desire to maintain unity can sometimes be used to discourage legitimate questions or concerns.


But the biblical commitment to honour does not exist independently of the biblical commitment to truth.


Jesus himself confronted religious leaders whose outward displays of righteousness concealed hypocrisy and injustice. He did not regard their positions as a reason to withhold criticism. In fact, their positions made their hypocrisy all the more significant.

Similarly, Paul publicly challenged Peter when his behaviour in Antioch contradicted the truth of the gospel (Galatians 2:11–14).


There is an important principle here: it is not dishonourable to tell the truth about wrongdoing.


Of course, the manner in which we confront others matters. We should not use truth as an excuse for cruelty, humiliation or vindictiveness. We are still called to speak the truth in love.

But neither should love become an excuse for silence.


Genuine honour does not require us to pretend that wrongdoing has not occurred. Nor does it require us to protect someone from the consequences of their actions. Indeed, sometimes the most honourable thing we can do for a person, and for those affected by their behaviour, is to confront the truth. Only when wrong-doing is allowed to be addressed, can their forgiveness and reconcilation.


A culture that protects reputation at the expense of truth has misunderstood honour.


The cross reveals the true nature of honour


Ultimately, I think the clearest way to understand biblical honour is to look at the cross.


In Philippians 2:5–11, Paul describes the humility of Christ. Although existing in the form of God, Christ did not regard equality with God as something to be exploited for his own advantage. Instead, he took the form of a servant, humbled himself and became obedient to death, even death on a cross.


The passage is remarkable because it connects humility, service, sacrifice and exaltation.

Christ's humiliation was not a denial of his true worth. Nor was his willingness to serve an indication that he lacked authority. Rather, it revealed the character of the one who possesses all authority.


And God exalted him.


There is a profound contrast here with toxic honour. Toxic honour is preoccupied with protecting one's position, maintaining one's reputation and avoiding humiliation. Christ demonstrates that true greatness is not threatened by humility or service.

He does not need to grasp at honour. He entrusts himself to the Father.

And this is the pattern Paul places before the Christian community: not looking to our own interests, but also to the interests of others.


A different kind of community


What would our churches, families and communities look like if we genuinely embraced this understanding of honour?


Imagine communities where leaders were more concerned with serving those under their care than protecting their own reputations. Where people could raise difficult questions without being treated as disloyal. Where the vulnerable were given particular attention rather than expected to defer to the powerful. Where recognition was freely given, authority was exercised with humility, and truth was valued more highly than appearances.


This would not be a community without authority, respect or appropriate forms of deference. The Bible certainly does not teach that all distinctions of responsibility and authority are meaningless.


But it would be a community in which authority existed for the benefit of others, rather than others existing to reinforce the authority of those above them. That is the distinction we need to recover.


Biblical honour is not about creating an environment in which everyone knows their place in a hierarchy. It is about creating a community in which everyone is treated according to the dignity God has given them.


A culture of toxic honour asks, Am I receiving the respect I deserve?

A culture of biblical honour asks, Am I giving others the respect and dignity they deserve?


The difference might seem subtle, but it changes almost everything about how we relate to one another.


The Christian understanding of honour begins not with our own status, but with the character of Christ. And when we understand the honour he has shown us, we begin to understand the honour we are called to show others.

Comments


Subscribe Form

©2019 by Stuart McEwing. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page